Surveying the landscape of aging in post-postmodern America with compassion, wit and a liberal slant. Only intermittently mature.

Friday, February 12, 2010

Farewell To Mr. Toad

I miss funerals.  That sounds funny coming from a member of the generation that has replaced casket burial with cremation as the official way to go, but I'm not talking about the box or lack of it.  I'm talking about the ceremonies we employ to help the living mark loss and build themselves a bridge to life after loss.  I miss the concept of "doing it right."

What got me started thinking about this was a call I received on my cell phone at 5:15 a.m., California time, from South Carolina, telling me that my neighbor of the past twenty years, Mr. Toad, had died during the night. The call came from his housekeeper who has done some work for us recently.  We talked about his years of COPD, his life since his wife died a few years ago, how he'd gotten impossibly bigger around the middle since then.  And I asked her about plans for the funeral.  I thought I could at least send flowers for the service and a card to the family, but my caller said Mr. Toad had chosen cremation and no service was planned.

Did you feel the empty at the end of that paragraph?  That's what I mean.

This strange, new absence of meaningful ritual is no good for us.  Humans need rite and ceremony, but we're in flux between the twentieth century way (when there was plenty of wood for caskets and plenty of land to place them in) and the new "right way" for this century.  A right way will develop and it will be embraced because it feels right and honors the values of this new era, for that's the way culture operates: old status--change--new status, and on, and on in an undulating wave pattern that has marked all known time. But these cultural transition periods, maybe especially this one, are as awkward and ugly as...as the word flux.


Our weddings, births rites, and funerals are all up for grabs in the name of individualism in the past two decades. Even as we insist on our right to redesign these rituals,  people have trouble at an unconscious level with the most important element of any ceremony: the feeling that we've somehow honored certain milestones the "right way."  When they receive an invitation, wedding guests don't know whether to sign on to the website and pony up for the destination wedding, to just monetize the honeymoon, or to call the mother of the bride and request silver pattern registration information.  The neighbors of the deceased don't know whether to dry clean the dark suit and change their plans for Thursday afternoon or...do nothing and try to act...how?

When each of my parents died, I knew to start phoning all their friends, contact one of the two funeral homes they were familiar with, put an announcement in their local paper, order the flowers, etc. As an only child, I was responsible for all the decisions, but I had inherited the template and only had to fill in the colors.  They were beautiful funerals with both chapel and graveside services, music, a soloist, flowers-- every tradition they had grown up with themselves.  They were exhausting efforts, but they gave me a place to put the buzzing current of energy inside me that alternated back and forth between denial and realization.  They were done the right way and I have had the comfort of knowing that.

I was told that Mr. Toad's daughter, several states away in the North, was trapped in her house under three feet of snow that had fallen in the latest wave of storms. All her planning was honed down to getting her city's snow plow to come dig her out so she could get to her Dad.  That just hurts my heart to hear about.

I wrote eulogies for each of my parents and had them read by the attending minister to my the friends and family who came to the funerals.  Of all the plans and decisions I made for my mother and father after they died, those eulogies were the most satisfying thing for me.  Anyone who wanted to speak in honor of my parents was invited to do so, too, and I know that the speakers were helped by it.  Mr. Toad's daughter will have to find what helps her; I deeply hope she finds the right way.

Had there been a funeral, here's what I might have stood to say:

Mr. Toad was a fine neighbor.  His loud bass croak was instantly recognizable when he called or hailed us across the yard.  He loaned his tools and gave back the ones he borrowed.  He kept an eye on our house and and we trusted him with a key.  He tolerated our son's garage band and even pretended to like the music, although even our son believes it was impossible to like.  He waved whenever he saw us and usually stopped to talk for a few minutes about hunting, or how the kids were doing, or the state of the lake we shared.  He asked for some ivy transplants for his yard and my husband was glad to put them in for him because he never asked us for much.  


Mr Toad would call us, very pleased with himself, when he found someone cheap to dig up a stump or put on a new roof; he loved to find bargain rate workers who actually showed up.  And he always followed the worker every step of the job, "supervising" with froggy-voiced instructions and criticisms, so he always had to find someone new to do the same type of job the next time.  


A few months ago, he phoned us while we were away to say that a muskrat had come to join us in residence at the lake and was tunneling under his yard.  He had discovered the tunnels when he stepped through the sod, up to his knee in the hole, and had a real struggle to get out.  I felt bad that we weren't at home at the time, because I know he would have croaked for us and we could have helped him...which calls up visions both comical and frightening.  Before we left to come west, I asked my husband if he had spoken to Mr. Toad in the last few days and he said he thought he remembered seeing the truck pull out of the driveway the day before.  We always wanted to let Mr. Toad know when we would be traveling, but we got rushed this time and didn't call.  I wish there was someplace to send flowers.  When we head east again, it's going to feel very strange to realize he's not in his rightful place in his home just beside ours. 


Farewell, Mr. Toad.

I used to think it was demanding for parents to lay out detailed instructions for how they wanted things to be handled after their death, but I'm re-thinking that.  It might be a real blessing to leave my kids with some direction in this odd cultural flux.  It almost doesn't matter what the directions are; I could say I wanted a service at the last skating rink in Myrtle Beach, with only chartreuse calla lilies and old Herbie Mann tracks played low while friends and family shared macaroni and cheese.  They could cuss me for an eccentric during the whole thing and it wouldn't really matter. What would eventually matter is that I made it easy for them to feel they'd done it right.

The Matter In Question:  Have you attended a service or planned a service that was non-traditional and, also, that "felt right"?  Have you given thought to your own service?  Should you plan or leave the plan up to others?  Has someone you've loved and lost left you at a loss for planning a service?  Do you hope your parents state their wishes or would you prefer that they leave it all up to you? Where is the whole matter of funeral headed?


[scoop.diamondgalleries.com/public/news_images]

8 comments:

  1. I know what you mean. I remember my Grabdparents' funerals with all the Roman Catholic frufferies.

    Mum's gone the other way. She wants no burial, no funeral. Donate her body to science and throw a party, get tipsy and laugh about all the wild things she'd done over the years.

    I guess I'll have to make a funeral ceremony from Mum for myself. One as full of life, love, and laughter as Mum herself always is.

    Hugs,
    GwenGuin
    ReplyDelete
  2. "Doing it right" for your parents is showing them that you've learned the lessons they taught and that you'll be fine without them... because you "know what to do."

    Writing my Dad's eulogy made me cry and laugh and review and reflect and I know he'd have enjoyed hearing it.... and I choose to believe that he really was listening.

    Mr. Toad was lucky to have you as neighbors.... as were you to have him.
    Rest in Peace, wherever you are, Mr. T.
    a/b
    ReplyDelete
  3. You've done more than "right" by your parents, my love. Acknowledging the need and value of the communications that takes place at the service, no matter what form, helps heal the wound of loss.
    ReplyDelete
  4. In my area of the South, in spite of the cosmopolitan leanings of the Raleigh-Durham area, funerals are still the standard. There is a crematorium near Chapel Hill but I don't personally know anyone who has used its services. Funerals are still a big deal. When my mother died in September 2008, the service was at the local Catholic Church. My parents converted to Catholicism when I was five. I and my two siblings were baptized and I was a practicing Catholic until I hit my 20s. Now I like to attend midnight mass at Christmas because I like the ritual and the music.

    I wrote the obituary for my mother and selected the music for the mass. My father was in no shape to make decisions. I found comfort in the planning. I needed something to do.
    ReplyDelete
  5. I am of two minds. Before her death, my mother asked that her casket be kept closed before she was buried. Her sister--and others--persuaded me to go against her wishes. The reason? All her friends needed to see her--that is, her remains--because that's what members of her generation expected. I was reluctant, but since funerals have nothing to do with the dead, only with those still alive, I adhered to the prevailing social conventions.

    As for cremation vs burial, there again I am of two minds. I want to be socially conscious, and I suppose that argues in favor of burning. At the same time, I balk at and feel the emptiness you describe in taking this path. Maybe ritual and "doing the right thing" should take precedence. Otherwise, we're in Brave New World, where the dead are recycled into their constituent chemicals, or Soylent Green, where the dead are processed into food pellets. Nothing appealing about either approach.
    You might enjoy taking a break from such serious issues by visiting http://drinksbeforedinner.com
    Barry Knister
    ReplyDelete
  6. I was sad to hear about the neighbor. I had spoken to him a few times myself. He was very thrilled that Marc finally got a woman. :) As for your funeral we will do anything you like...but since I have decided that you will live forever, no need in discussing it right now. Dad's funeral was surreal and thankfully the shock of how quickly it happened allowed me to make the decisions that seem so hard at that time.
    ReplyDelete
  7. As always, a thoughtful and thought-provoking post. Flux indeed.

    I admit that I have mapped out my mom's final steps. Her Alzheimer's and my dad's death more than thirty years ago pretty much leaves it to my brothers and me.

    My own death has been considered as well, but that's best left for another time. Ironically, I'm likely changing weekend travel plans to take in a full blown funeral for a colleague, who passed this morning, but plans are still up in the air.

    A toast to your late friend and neighbor.
    ReplyDelete
  8. Lovely, thoughtful post. A whole novel, really, in one post.
    ReplyDelete

Lurking allowed. Commenting adored.